1954 1 Ted Williams Red Sox
1955 2 Ted Williams Red Sox
1956 3 Elmer Valo KC A's
1957 4 Johnny Logan Braves
1958 5 Willie Mays Giants
1959 6 Alex Grammas Cardinals The Diamond King
1960 7 Master & Mentor Giants
1961 8 Dick Williams KC A's
1962 9 Jim Davenport Giants
1963 10 AL Strikeout Ldrs The Diamond King
1964 11 NL RBI ldrs
1965 12 NL SO Ldrs
1966 13 Lou Johnson Dodgers gcrl
1967 14 Joe Sparma Tigers
1968 15 Ron Hunt Dodgers
1969 16 Giants Rookies Stars Giants gcrl
1970 17 Hoyt Wilhem Braves Gavin
1971 18 Norm Miller Astros The Diamond King/gcrl
1972 19 Billy Cowan Angels gcrl
1973 20 Stan Bahnsen White Sox Baseball Cards Come to Life
1974 21 Bob Gallagher Astros gcrl
1975 22 Dave Cash Phillies
1976 23 Brian Downing White Sox Baseball Cards Come to Life
1977 24 Carl Morton Braves Baseball Cards Come to Life
1978 25 Jon Matlack Mets
1979 26 Jamie Quirk Royals
1980 27 Del Unser Phillies
1981 28 Enrique Romo Pirates Angels in Order
1982 29 Dwayne Murphy
1983 30 Jim Rice Red Sox The Diamond King
1984 31 Andy McCaffigan Giants Angels in Order
1985 32 Chuck Porter Brewers Baseball Cards Come to Life
1986 33 Jeff Lahti Cardinals Angels in Order
1987 34 Jose Rijo A's Angels in Order
1988 35 Harold Baines White Sox Baseball Cards Come to Life/The Cooperstown Advocate
1989 36 Mitch Webster Cubs Baseball Cards Come to Life
1990 37 Domingo Ramos Cubs Baseball Cards Come to Life/The Cooperstown Advocate
1991 38 Scott Bradley Seattle Baseball Cards Come to Life
1992 39 Greg Olson Braves
1993 40 Ozzie Smith Cardinals
1994 41 Kevin Wickander Reds Baseball Cards Come to Life
1995 42 Jose Batista Cubs
1996 43 Troy Percival Angels Angels in Order
1997 44 Hal Morris Reds Baseball Cards Come to Life
1998 45 Pat Hentgen Toronto Baseball Cards Come to Life
1999 46 Armando Benitez Baltimore
2000 47 Shannon Stewart Toronto
2001 48 Dan Plesac Arizona
2002 49 Ben Petrick Colorado
2003 50 Sammy Sosa Cubs The Diamond King
2004 51 Danny Graves Reds Baseball Cards Come to Life
2005 52 Danny Graves Reds
2006 53 Tomo Okha Brewers Baseball Cards Come to Life
2007 54 Daniel Cabrera Baltimore Baseball Cards Come to Life
2008 55 Chris Young San Diego Baseball Cards Come to Life
2009 56 Edwin Encarcion Reds Baseball Cards Come to Life
2010 57 CC Sabithia Yankees Baseball Cards Come to Life
2011 58 Josh Johnson Miami Baseball Cards Come to Life
2012 59 Texas Rangers
2013 60 Jon Rauch Mets Baseball Cards Come to Life
2014 61 Nick Markakis Baltimore
2015 62 Nolan Arrenado Colorado Baseball Cards Come to Life
2016 63 Zach Britton Baltimore
2017 64 Adam Eaton White Sox
2018 65 Alex Wood Dodgers Angels in Order
2019 66 Stephen Piscotty Yankees
2020 67 Tyler Beede Giants
2021 68 Charlie Blackmon
2022 69 Corey Kluber Yankees
2023 70